The Employment Rights reforms will affect all UK employers — but for hospitality businesses in Scotland, the operational impact is likely to be more pronounced.
Scottish hotels, restaurants, bars and event venues operate in a uniquely volatile environment. Tourism fluctuates. Weather impacts footfall. Events create unpredictable peaks and troughs. Many businesses rely on flexible staffing models to absorb this variability.
When employment rules tighten around shift predictability, sick pay, contract stability and dismissal protections, that volatility becomes a financial and legal risk factor.
For a typical 50-person hospitality business paying an average of £13.50 per hour, the reforms do not automatically create a crisis — but they do significantly reduce tolerance for reactive workforce practices.
Below is where exposure is most likely to arise — and how HR structure affects that exposure.
Why Scottish Hospitality Faces Higher Risk
Several structural characteristics amplify the impact of employment reform in this sector:
- High rota volatility driven by tourism and weather
- Frequent short-notice shift changes
- Heavy reliance on zero-hours or flexible staffing
- Higher short-term sickness frequency
- High employee turnover (often 30–50%)
- Late-night trading and alcohol-related conduct risk
- A younger, seasonal or multi-job workforce
These features combine to create pressure in three primary areas: shift management, contract structure and absence control.
1. Shift Cancellations and Short-Notice Changes
Hospitality businesses often adjust staffing levels in response to:
- Booking cancellations
- Weather-related downturns
- Event changes
- Lower-than-forecast trading
Under stronger employment protections, short-notice cancellations or curtailed shifts may trigger compensation requirements.
For illustration:
At £13.50 per hour, cancelling one six-hour shift per week equates to approximately £4,200 per year.
Five to six cancellations per week can exceed £25,000 annually.
In a sector built on demand variability, this is the most significant structural cost risk.
2. Zero-Hours Contracts and Predictable Hours Reform
Flexible staffing is central to hospitality operations. However, where “casual” staff consistently work stable weekly hours, employers may be required to offer contracts reflecting that pattern.
Many venues currently reduce hours during quieter winter periods. If that flexibility narrows, payroll becomes less elastic.
For a 50-person operation, structural payroll increases of £7,000–£15,000 annually are realistic depending on how embedded flexible staff are within the rota.
The key management question is:
Are flexible staff genuinely occasional — or functioning as part of the core workforce?
3. Sick Pay and Absence Management
Hospitality environments typically experience:
- Higher short-term sickness
- Contagious illness exposure
- Weekend or event-related absence spikes
If average sickness increases by just one additional paid day per employee per year, the cost for a 50-person business is approximately £5,400. Two additional days doubles that figure.
Where absence monitoring is informal or return-to-work interviews are inconsistent, these costs can escalate gradually but materially.
4. Dismissal and Probation Risk
High turnover combined with informal management styles increases exposure to procedural dismissal risk.
Tribunal defence costs commonly range between £5,000–£15,000 even where the employer is successful.
Structured probation reviews, documented performance discussions and HR oversight significantly reduce this volatility.
The HR Structure Question: Internal vs Outsourced
How a hospitality business structures HR support now plays a direct role in managing reform-related risk.
No Dedicated HR (Manager-Led)
Many 50-person venues operate without formal HR support, relying on managers.
Advantages:
- Lowest direct cost
- Operational flexibility
Risks:
- Higher procedural errors in dismissal
- Weak absence documentation
- Poor shift audit trails
- Greater tribunal exposure
This model keeps fixed costs low but increases volatility.
Outsourced HR (Common SME Model)
Typical retained HR support ranges from £400–£700 per month.
Advantages:
- Policy updates and compliance guidance
- Support before dismissals
- Structured absence and disciplinary advice
- Reduced tribunal exposure
- Predictable annual cost
For hospitality businesses, outsourced HR often provides the strongest cost–risk balance. A competent adviser can offset their fee by:
- Reducing cancellation practices
- Tightening absence management
- Avoiding one defended tribunal claim
Internal HR (Part-Time or Full-Time)
Some 50-person operators consider part-time HR roles (approx. £18k–£22k annual cost including on-costs).
Advantages:
- Embedded cultural oversight
- Proactive absence management
- Stronger dismissal process control
- Improved documentation
Challenges:
- Significant fixed cost
- May be underutilised outside peak periods
Full-time HR is rarely cost-justified at 50 staff unless turnover or complexity is unusually high.
Financial Perspective
For a Scottish hospitality business with payroll around £1.3 million:
- Controlled implementation may limit impact to 2–3% of payroll
- High rota volatility, structural casual staffing and rising absence can push impact toward 5–6%
HR structure does not eliminate cost — but it does influence volatility and legal exposure.
The greatest cost sensitivity remains:
- Cancellation frequency
- Whether zero-hours staff operate as core employees
- Average sickness days per employee
HR oversight primarily influences the third and fourth risk areas — absence and dismissal — and can indirectly influence rota discipline.
The Strategic Takeaway
The reforms do not remove flexibility from Scottish hospitality — but they do require more deliberate workforce planning.
Operators most exposed are those that rely on:
- Reactive rota adjustments
- Structural casual labour
- Informal absence management
- Unstructured dismissals
Businesses that formalise scheduling, audit zero-hours patterns and strengthen process controls will be best positioned to contain cost impact and avoid litigation.
The question for hospitality operators is no longer simply compliance.
It is whether current workforce practices are sustainable in a more regulated operating environment.
We have added a recent case study below.
Call us on 07984 568523 to arrange an appointment to discuss how we can help your business.
